does this image bother YOU?
This news just in:
Jesus has been depicted in many different ways throughout history, but a new sculpture in downtown Toronto — as a homeless man sleeping on a bench — is causing quite a stir. According to the Toronto Star, the sculpture was “rejected by two prominent Catholic churches, St. Michael’s Cathedral in Toronto and St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York.” Despite the fact that “Rectors of both cathedrals were enthusiastic about the bronze piece,” superiors in both the Toronto and New York archdiocese turned it down. The sculptor, Timothy Schmalz says,
However, not everyone is comfortable with these types of
interpretations of Jesus. A mission in Branson, Missouri, called “Jesus
Was Homeless,” which is run by Bryan and Amy Stallings, that serves
about 1,000 homeless a week has fallen under scrutiny for their chosen
name. Stallings says critics tell them that “Jesus wasn’t homeless,” but
once he references Scripture, “it sparks tons of conversation.” He
explains,
Reverend Gordon Dixon, the dean of the Jesuit college that is now
home to Schmalz’s sculpture says, “It’s one of the most inviting and
authentic representations of Jesus. There’s the suggestion there is the
king and he is answering our culture with his poverty, vulnerability and
weakness.”
Reverend Baum's opinion: People can't stand it when something is blatantly put out there, such as homelessness. Even religion has to be "kept clean." Note the corpus hung in every Catholic Church practically worldwide....only tiny marks on His hands and feet and a small slit in His side are visible....if you watched "The Passion of the Christ," that was more in keeping with what Jesus suffered, but we are so antiseptic in our thinking--don't show the blood and gore! And why? Is it because if we see homeless people, then we have to deal with it...or else turn our heads and walk away? Friends, this is the sad, sorry reality of our life! It isn't just in America, being homeless is just as prevalent in Europe, in Africa....my daughter, who returned from a week long trip to Paris, France said that the homeless sleep on bare concrete with their children beside them. They beg or steal for every little thing. They have no social programs such as we do here in America. Poverty is so "in your face" in what is "supposed" to be a vacation spot.
What is your position about this topic? Is this sculpture too "real" for you...or does it move you to compassion?
Think about it...what if it were you? Our futures our not guaranteed. Many are just one paycheck away from financial disaster. Would you appreciate being ignored in your time of need? Does my even referring to it make you uncomfortable?
I hope it does. I hope it causes you to think...and then...to ACT!
Jesus has been depicted in many different ways throughout history, but a new sculpture in downtown Toronto — as a homeless man sleeping on a bench — is causing quite a stir. According to the Toronto Star, the sculpture was “rejected by two prominent Catholic churches, St. Michael’s Cathedral in Toronto and St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York.” Despite the fact that “Rectors of both cathedrals were enthusiastic about the bronze piece,” superiors in both the Toronto and New York archdiocese turned it down. The sculptor, Timothy Schmalz says,
"Homeless Jesus had no home. How ironic. It was very upsetting because the rectors liked it, but when it got to the administration, people thought it might be too controversial or vague."
He was told “it was not an appropriate image.”
The sculpture, whose message is “Jesus identifying with the poorest
among us,” finally found a home outside Regis College at the University
of Toronto. According to the Star, Regis college is a “Jesuit school of
theology, where priests and lay people are trained, with an emphasis on
social justice.” When theologian Thomas Reynolds first saw the
sculpture, he says he felt “the shock of recognition,” and quoted the
biblical passage, “… the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.”
Reynolds explains that he is “used to seeing imaged of Jesus that are
palatable,” but the sculpture of Jesus as a homeless man is
“provocative” because it “punctures the illusion of normalcy.” He says,
In certain ways, Christian communities have been privileged and considered themselves the norm in society and that has made Christians comfortable in our complacency.
People who have issue with it are usually the staunch religious people, especially those who follow prosperity teaching and doctrine that says if you are homeless or poor you don’t have enough faith.
Reverend Baum's opinion: People can't stand it when something is blatantly put out there, such as homelessness. Even religion has to be "kept clean." Note the corpus hung in every Catholic Church practically worldwide....only tiny marks on His hands and feet and a small slit in His side are visible....if you watched "The Passion of the Christ," that was more in keeping with what Jesus suffered, but we are so antiseptic in our thinking--don't show the blood and gore! And why? Is it because if we see homeless people, then we have to deal with it...or else turn our heads and walk away? Friends, this is the sad, sorry reality of our life! It isn't just in America, being homeless is just as prevalent in Europe, in Africa....my daughter, who returned from a week long trip to Paris, France said that the homeless sleep on bare concrete with their children beside them. They beg or steal for every little thing. They have no social programs such as we do here in America. Poverty is so "in your face" in what is "supposed" to be a vacation spot.
What is your position about this topic? Is this sculpture too "real" for you...or does it move you to compassion?
Think about it...what if it were you? Our futures our not guaranteed. Many are just one paycheck away from financial disaster. Would you appreciate being ignored in your time of need? Does my even referring to it make you uncomfortable?
I hope it does. I hope it causes you to think...and then...to ACT!
We think that life here in America, the land of plenty is a good one. I have seen the homeless and not just in big cities. They are all over the small towns as well. But what can we do to reach out? There are so many!
ReplyDeleteI can look at a statue, it's the real thing that bothers me!
ReplyDeleteI'll bet Pope Francis would have appreciated this!
ReplyDeleteI am thinking that Jesus approves of this....the only reason some have issues is because, as you said, everything in life has to be tidy. "Sweep the social issues under the rug and move along, people. There's nothing here to look at!"
ReplyDelete